Go to content
Photo: Samuli Hellman

Comparison of regional policies in the Nordic countries

A comparative analysis of the Nordic countries’ national regional policies highlights similarities in focus, roles and funding mechanisms. The comparison also explores whether and how civil preparedness is addressed in regional policies and identifies opportunities for improvement.

Focus of the Nordic countries' regional policies

An examination of regional policies within each Nordic country’s administrative framework reveals shared priorities, including growth, sustainability, cohesion and development, across their territories.
As outlined in Table 1, Denmark prioritises geographical balance with a particular emphasis on rural areas, while Finland, Sweden and Åland emphasise increased regional sustainability and competitiveness. The Faroe Islands and Greenland focus on achieving balanced development and enhancing living conditions within their territories. Norway’s regional policy is designed to promote good living conditions nationwide while supporting community development and population growth. Iceland, which does not have a specific definition of regional policy, implements a strategic regional development plan aimed at fostering growth and enhancing  cooperation across institutional levels.
Country
Focus of regional policy
Denmark
The government envisions a Denmark in geographical balance, with a special focus on strengthening and supporting rural areas (By-, Land- og Kirkeministeriet, 2024).
Finland
Promoting sustainable and inclusive growth, competitiveness, citizen well-being and reducing regional disparities (Arbets- och näringsministeriet, 2024).
Faroe Islands
Ensuring balanced development and improving living conditions across all regions through specific objectives and initiatives (Samgonguskjal, 2022).
Greenland
Adopting a holistic approach to regional development, with the aim of enhancing economic, social and environmental well-being across all regions (Departementet for Sociale Anliggender og Arbejdsmarked, 2022).
Iceland
While lacking a specific definition of regional policy, Iceland employs a strategic regional development plan to promote growth, sustainable development and improved intergovernmental cooperation (Althingi, 2022).
Norway
The aim is to enable all citizens to live good lives nationwide, foster local community development and support population growth in district municipalities (Regjeringen, 2023a; 2023b).
Sweden
Strengthening local and regional competitiveness to achieve sustainable development across the country (Näringsdepartementet, 2022; Regeringens skrivelse, 2020).
Åland
Future-proofing healthcare and social care, investing in safe and sustainable transport, maintaining high Nordic welfare standards and achieving the goals of the sustainability agenda (Bärkraft, 2023; Ålands landskapsregering, 2023).
(Authors' summary)

Table 1: Focus of regional policy in the Nordic countries
Country
Focus of regional policy
Denmark
The government envisions a Denmark in geographical balance, with a special focus on strengthening and supporting rural areas (By-, Land- og Kirkeministeriet, 2024).
Finland
Promoting sustainable and inclusive growth, competitiveness, citizen well-being and reducing regional disparities (Arbets- och näringsministeriet, 2024).
Faroe Islands
Ensuring balanced development and improving living conditions across all regions through specific objectives and initiatives (Samgonguskjal, 2022).
Greenland
Adopting a holistic approach to regional development, with the aim of enhancing economic, social and environmental well-being across all regions (Departementet for Sociale Anliggender og Arbejdsmarked, 2022).
Iceland
While lacking a specific definition of regional policy, Iceland employs a strategic regional development plan to promote growth, sustainable development and improved intergovernmental cooperation (Althingi, 2022).
Norway
The aim is to enable all citizens to live good lives nationwide, foster local community development and support population growth in district municipalities (Regjeringen, 2023a; 2023b).
Sweden
Strengthening local and regional competitiveness to achieve sustainable development across the country (Näringsdepartementet, 2022; Regeringens skrivelse, 2020).
Åland
Future-proofing healthcare and social care, investing in safe and sustainable transport, maintaining high Nordic welfare standards and achieving the goals of the sustainability agenda (Bärkraft, 2023; Ålands landskapsregering, 2023).
(Authors' summary)

Table 1: Focus of regional policy in the Nordic countries

Roles and responsibilities in Nordic regional policy

The five Nordic countries and the three autonomous regions differ in their approaches to the roles and responsibilities associated with developing and implementing regional policy (Slätmo & Bogason, 2024; Slätmo et al., 2022; Tillväxtanalys, 2021). In Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden, the responsibility for formulating and executing regional development strategies rests with regional entities
Discussions regarding regional policy in Denmark, which form part of the background to this project, reveal some reluctance to assign responsibility for regional policy to the regional level of administration. Among certain actors, what is referred to as "regional policy" in Denmark is instead perceived as state-level business policy targeted at municipalities.
. The institutional units responsible for regional policy are referred to as “regioner” (regions) in Denmark and Sweden, “landskapsförbund/ maakuntien liitot” (regional councils) in Finland and “fylkeskommuner” (county councils) in Norway. In both Denmark and Sweden, the regions manage healthcare and public transport. However, the responsibility for business development, which lies with the regions and municipalities in Sweden, is centralised at the national and municipal levels in Denmark. In several Nordic countries, government agencies also maintain regional offices that play a significant role in implementing and monitoring regional policy. For example, in Sweden, the County Administrative Boards (Länsstyrelserna) are entrusted with that task, while in Norway that role is performed by the State Governor (Statsforvalteren). The division of responsibilities in Iceland and the autonomous regions of Åland, the Faroe Islands and Greenland follows a different model, with growth and cohesion policies shared between national authorities and municipalities (Slätmo et al., 2022).
The responsibilities of regional public administration units in the Nordic countries are continuously evolving (Dølvik et al., 2015; Slätmo et al., 2022; Tillväxtanalys, 2021). In addition to the regional policy units mentioned above, other regional actors and institutional structures also play a role in the governance framework. For instance, in Finland, welfare areas are tasked with managing social and health services, as well as rescue services (Social- och hälsovårdsministeriet, 2024). In Sweden, civil defence areas were introduced in 2022, with the County Administrative Boards divided into six civil areas aimed at strengthening national resilience during peacetime crises, heightened preparedness and war. Each area is led by a designated county administrative board, with the county governor serving as the head of the civil area (Asp, 2023; Länsstyrelsen Stockholm, 2024).

The role of the state in policy design and implementation of regional development in the Nordic Region

In an analysis of state-led regional and rural policies in the Nordic countries, particularly regarding access to basic services, Slätmo and Bogason (2024) identified two distinct approaches to the division of roles and responsibilities within public administration. The first model assigns regional and municipal actors the responsibility for developing place-based growth strategies, drawing on national frameworks for cohesion, growth and sustainable development. The second model treats regional policy and development as state or national responsibilities, with a stronger delegation of implementation to municipalities, where central decisions are executed locally (Slätmo & Bogason, 2024) (See Table 2).
Denmark
Faroe Islands
Finland
Greenland
Iceland
Norway
Sweden
Åland
Government delegates a great deal of responsibility for the development and implementation of regional policy
x
 
x
 
 
x
x
 
Government is responsible for policy development and delegates part of the implementation
x
x
 
x
x
 
 
x
Table 2: Two general approaches to regional policy development and implementation in the Nordic countries
DK
FO
FI
GL
IS
NO
SE
AX
Government delegates a great deal of responsibility for the development and imple-mentation of regional policy
x
 
x
 
 
x
x
 
Government is responsible for policy development and dele-gates part of the imple-mentation
x
x
 
x
x
 
 
x
Table 2: Two general approaches to regional policy development and implementation in the Nordic countries
The two approaches to regional policy have both advantages and disadvantages. From a governmental perspective, devolution is advantageous, as it enables place-based regional development, where the specific needs and drivers of growth in different areas can be incorporated into the design of strategic interventions. That approach is beneficial in terms of policy relevance and fosters regional and local ownership. Such strategies have long been advocated in regional and rural development research. However, delegated responsibility can present challenges for the state when it comes to ensuring the quality of regional policy direction and implementation. Quality is often assessed using general templates and indicators, such as access to services, population size, types of employment and skills enhancement programmes.
Furthermore, also from the national governmental perspective, an approach that involves centralisation of responsibility for policy development, while implementation is delegated, can streamline policy interventions and ensure that taxpayers' money is spent on areas deemed most relevant by the government. The key challenge here is to account for regional diversity, i.e. to recognise that different areas within a country have varying needs and therefore require tailored interventions (Slätmo & Bogason, 2024).

Municipalities and regions in regional development policy

Even in the Nordic countries that have a formal regional level of government – Denmark, Finland, Sweden and Norway – the responsibilities of municipalities tend to be broader than those of regional authorities. According to the Local Autonomy Index (LAI), Nordic municipalities have extensive statutory tasks and autonomy, such as local taxation rights and significant freedom in shaping their organisational structures (Sandberg, 2023). In the comparison of 57 countries, Finland, Denmark, Iceland and Sweden rank among those with the strongest municipal autonomy, with index values above 70 on a scale of 0-100 (Sandberg, 2023, p.6). Norway, with an index value of 69, is not in the same category, but differs only minimally from the other Nordic countries. However, Norway stands apart from the rest in that the economic ties between the state and municipalities are stronger. That is because taxation rights in Norway are nominal, meaning they are governed by state frameworks and legislated tax levels (Sandberg, 2023, p. 6). Iceland's municipalities enjoy relatively more independence from state intervention, but they have fewer tasks than municipalities in the other Nordic countries.
’Smart specialisation’ is one of the tools used today to address local and regional growth challenges. Other current regional policy approaches include supporting and facilitating industrial symbiosis, business clusters and circular energy and material flows.
Another important tool is strategic spatial planning, in which policy objectives are concretised and prioritised using maps and geographical structural images produced through inclusive participatory processes. Municipalities are responsible for spatial land use planning in all Nordic countries (Lidmo et al., 2020), though other tasks and mandates vary between the countries (Sandberg, 2023). Although their roles are not always clearly defined, municipalities are expected to contribute to regional initiatives for sustainability and growth. For example, inter-municipal cooperation for spatial planning can be leveraged in areas that are sensitive to changes, and for societal and industrial establishments that will have large impacts, such as the location of mines, energy supplies and hospitals, and the management of water resources.

Financing of Nordic regional policy

The government funding allocated to regional development in the Nordic countries is fairly limited compared to other expenditure areas. This segment of policy is often referred to as 'small regional policy' or 'targeted regional policy'. Regional development policy does, however, require a broad range of interventions across multiple policy and spending areas. The part of national level policy that addresses sectoral areas is sometimes called "major regional policy" (Tillväxtanalys, 2021), which suggests that most of a country's political decisions, directives and laws have a regional and municipal impact. National policy, in this context, sets the framework for territorial – or regional – development. That includes national policies and budgets for labour markets, education, industry, transport, the environment and digitalisation. For the Nordic countries that are members of the EU, the EU is also a significant source of funding for regional policy. Furthermore, regions and municipalities contribute through their own tax revenues.
Some of the components of regional policy and civil preparedness
Figure 1: Some of the components of regional policy and civil preparedness

Civil preparedness in Nordic regional policy

As part of this project, the regional policies of each Nordic country (Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden) and of the autonomous regions (the Faroe Islands, Greenland and Åland) were examined to assess whether civil preparedness is integrated into current regional policy documents. Table 3 provides an overview based on those documents, supplemented by insights from regional stakeholders and lessons learnt from the assessment.
To clarify the focus, the regional policy documents were searched for aspects that we define as civil preparedness within the scope of this project. Those aspects entail prevention and security measures, emergency services, crisis preparedness, food security (including food supply, agriculture and food production), energy supply, raw materials (particularly minerals and metals) and access to (public) services. Since the primary policies in these areas are sectoral policies, it is not surprising that they were not always explicitly mentioned in the regional policies reviewed.
Given the dynamic nature of society and the environment, along with the ongoing pursuit of a green transition, it is increasingly important for civil preparedness to also address the impacts of that transition. By identifying potential strengths and weaknesses, the study highlights opportunities to further strengthen civil preparedness within Nordic regional policies.
Strengths to build on
Weaknesses to improve
Civil protection (societal measures for prevention and safety)
Included in regional policy in Finland, the Faroe Islands, Greenland, Iceland, Norway and Åland, primarily as an overall horizontal issue.
In all five countries and three self-autonomous regions, there is a need for greater clarity regarding objectives and division of roles to allocate time and resources for high-quality implementation. In particular, there is scope to focus further on civil preparedness in governmental regional development policy in Denmark and to some extent in Sweden.

In Denmark, regional actors note that regional and municipal actors should be able to integrate a civil preparedness perspective more effectively into their work. Coherent strategies, the possibility to implement actions and adequate allocated resources are necessary.

In Sweden, clearer guidelines, standardised expectations and requirements set out by the government would facilitate preparedness-related work at the regional levels.

In Norway, the role of counties in preparedness work is considered unclear from the regional level representatives, and it is important that this role be clarified in the relevant legislation.
Crisis management (Rescue services such as fire brigades, ambulance and medics, and police)
Included in regional policy in Finland, the Faroe Islands, Greenland, Iceland, Norway and Åland.
There are several good examples to learn from, such as cooperation concerning the fire brigade in Åland and Nordic cross-border rescue service cooperation (Nordred).
Not included in current state level regional policy documents in Sweden and Denmark.
Food security (food supply, agriculture and food production)
Included in regional policy in Denmark, Finland, the Faroe Islands, Norway, Sweden and Åland.
The Nordic ministers for fisheries, agriculture, food and forestry agreed in June 2024 to strengthen cooperation on preparedness and resilience in the field of food security and forests (Nordiskt samarbete, 2024a).
Greenland and Iceland can strengthen these aspects. National levels may need to conclude agreements on parameters to remove or bypass tariffs between Finland, Sweden (on the one hand) and Norway (on the other hand) during crises or war.
 
Energy supply
Included in regional policy in Denmark, Finland, the Faroe Islands, Greenland, Iceland, Sweden and Åland.
In October 2024, the Nordic energy ministers agreed on enhanced cooperation on energy, offering opportunities to find common solutions and learn from each other's strategies for electricity and energy (Nordiskt samarbete, 2024b).
The role of the regions, and especially the use of spatial planning to ensure regional energy supply could be enhanced in all five countries and three self-autonomous regions.
Moreover, in Norway, the energy supply in regional policy could be clarified and defined in more detail.
Supply of raw materials (primarily minerals and metals)
Included in the national regional policies of Norway, the Faroe Islands and Greenland.

In October 2024, Nordic ministers for economic affairs agreed on a new partnership for critical minerals and metals. That agreement can serve as an opportunity to find common solutions or learn from each other's strategies. (Nordiskt samarbete, 2024c)
Regional policies in Sweden, Finland and Åland address the need to close material flows, recycle and reuse, which can indirectly reduce the need for raw materials. Improvements are needed, as raw materials are not taken into account in regional policy in Denmark or Iceland.

The role of the regions, and especially the use of spatial planning to integrate a perspective of raw materials in development could be enhanced in all five countries and three self-autonomous regions.
Access to (public) services (school, health care, transport)
Included in the regional policies of all countries and regions.
Transport is highlighted as particularly important for the Border Committees, which manage flows between countries. It is also emphasised as critical for the Faroe Islands and Åland. As noted by Enestam (2021), political governance of digital and physical infrastructure at the Nordic level may need to be strengthened.
Table 3: Assessment of whether and how civil preparedness is included in national regional policies in the Nordic countries, including brief lessons learnt (authors' weighted assessment of regional policy documents in Denmark, Finland, the Faroe Islands, Greenland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden and Åland)
Civil preparedness has received some attention in regional policy within the Nordic countries, although it does not feature prominently (Table 3). The core of regional policy has been largely focused on growth-promoting measures and support mechanisms aimed at levelling out regional differences. Variations in physical conditions and resources, demographics, lifestyles and economies shape how civil preparedness can and should be developed. That highlights the need for geographical, regional and local customisation in civil preparedness. Research on sustainable and equitable risk management suggests that such contextual adaptation is necessary (Bourdin et al., 2023; de Goër de Herve et al., 2023). The regional and municipal levels play a crucial role in facilitating that adaptation.
Previous studies also indicate that rescue services, such as police presence, is to a certain degree incorporated into rural and regional policy in Denmark, Finland, the Faroe Islands, Norway and Åland. However, Greenland, Iceland and Sweden do not address that issue specifically from a regional or rural perspective (Slätmo et al., 2022). Those findings, when combined with the results presented in Table 3, suggest opportunities for learning and the exchange of best practices across countries.
According to Tillväxtanalys (2021), economic resilience is managed differently across the Nordic countries. Denmark and Sweden incorporate economic resilience into their existing governance structures through regular meetings involving key stakeholders with the necessary mandates, whereas Finland and Norway use specific governance tools for economic crisis preparedness, such as financial support measures and expert committees. Together, those governance models provide a framework through which increased financial resilience can be achieved by leveraging existing governance structures for both regular meetings and the provision of financial crisis tools when necessary.