Go to content

Photo: Kateryna Hliznitsova, unsplash.com

Recommendations

The process of developing recommendations

This chapter presents the reflections of the core project team, which was responsible for developing the recommendations. It provides context and insight into the complexities surrounding gender equality and highlights both the challenges and the breakthroughs that have been achieved in this area. The "Share the Care" project builds on the previous "Men in Nursing Education" project and is situated within a broader discourse on gender equality and representation in the workforce, particularly in relation to traditionally gendered roles. Historically, women's movements have sought to achieve equal representation in fields where men are in the majority, such as the medical sector. However, we now find ourselves advocating for men's representation in caring professions like nursing. It is notable that men have not been driven by structural barriers to seek inclusion in nursing professions. Rather, their entry into such roles often stems from a personal interest in meaningful work, instead of a desire to dismantle gender inequalities. Instead, it is society’s quest for greater diversity and balance in nursing, which is driven by multiple factors: the desire for more diverse care provision and utilisation of the full potential of the labour force. That paradox is one of the project's most profound revelations – a contrast between men not fighting for their inclusion in caring professions and society's fight on their behalf. Consequently, the gender imbalance in the caring professions reflects broader social and structural inequalities, as does the fight (or lack of fight) for equal representation.
In light of the aforementioned paradox, it is important to acknowledge the prevailing sense of inertia surrounding the project. That is due to the fact that the topic of gender equality in the nursing profession has been discussed on numerous occasions, leading to the perception that the impact remains minimal. That is another crucial contextual factor that has informed the work of the core project team in formulating these recommendations. The most crucial question that this project raises is whether nursing will continue to be perceived as a female profession or whether that perception can be altered in the future. One of the most significant challenges to be addressed is the need to alter attitudes. Creating long-lasting change requires a consistent and focused effort by society at large.
Going forward, in developing the recommendations, we have decided to rely on immediate actors who can take certain practical steps, as a more targeted approach with fewer steps could yield more significant results. The aim of the recommendations is to provide a framework for the action that should be taken to implement the change. It is vital that we pursue international collaboration, attract funding for these issues and encourage crucial stakeholders to become actively involved in the effort by integrating diversity initiatives that extend beyond formal documents and are rather “living labs for diversity in healthcare”. It is vital to continue the conversation on gender equality in caring professions to ensure success of the project. As the project highlighted, achieving gender balance in nursing is not merely about representation; it is about reshaping societal attitudes and understanding the actual factors that contribute to success in an inclusive environment.

Structuring of the recommendations

The "Share the Care" project was based on six core tasks. However, the recommendations were developed according to a number of additional dimensions, including time, impact, the unit of the administrative body responsible for change and costs required to implement the change. That structure was designed to provide an accessible overview of the recommendations, enabling higher education representatives and policymakers to identify the most suitable ones for immediate implementation, while also allowing them to consider more long-term strategic objectives.

These are the principle take-home messages from the projects: 

  1. De facto commitment to diversity
It is crucial for universities and faculties to engage proactively with diversity and gender equality through the formulation and implementation of specific action plans or diversity plans. That entails ensuring university action plans have a dual focus on female professors' representation among academic staff and achieving gender balance among students. Linking such initiatives to national diversity and gender equality strategies is vital for sustained progress. Faculty leadership must prioritise and assume ownership of this issue to facilitate networking with other institutions and drive continuous improvement.
  1. Support systems for male students in nursing education
It is recommended that male students be grouped together in classes and given peer support. Additionally, implementing mentoring systems, including female mentors, has proven effective in preventing dropouts and improving the well-being of male students in nursing education and the profession. Field practice (clinical practice) environments should also be structured to support the retention and success of male students.
  1. Recruitment strategies tailored to male candidates
To attract more male candidates to nursing, it is important to highlight the diverse career pathways available, especially in traditionally masculine fields like emergency care, psychiatric care and other healthcare specialities. Recruitment strategies and communication materials should be updated to appeal to a more diverse audience, considering factors like gender, ethnicity and age, while emphasising the meaningful and purposeful aspects of nursing.
  1. Diversity awareness training for all 
It is essential that within the university all study programmes place an emphasis on gender equality, inclusivity and diversity education. Targeted educational activities should be developed both for faculty members (teachers, clinical practice leaders and others), as well as all students. Diversity training that includes reflection on gendered and ethnic identities is of utmost importance for all. That enables not only male students, but all students to gain a deeper understanding of the challenges and dynamics associated with being a minority or majority group within a gendered field like nursing, leading to more inclusive care in the Nordic Region and beyond.

Table of recommendations

Below is a summary of specific, practical recommendations that can be implemented at different administrative levels, starting at the faculty level and then moving onto the university level, as well as the regional and national level.
Administrative layer
Recommendation
Time frame
Impact
Cost/budget
Description 
Faculty
Group male students (and male practitioners) together 
Short-term
(6-12 months)
Makes male students feel belonging to a group and build supportive ties within the educational institution and beyond
Low (coordination, promotion)
It is recommended that men be grouped together in classes, provided with peer support, and given access to mentoring systems (including also female mentors). In this way they are given the necessary support to experience feelings of belonging the the educational institution and profession or nursing in general
Faculty
Revise recruitment materials and language used to ensure gender-neutral and inclusive language, removing stereotypical images and texts
Short-term
(6-12 months)
Changes perception of nursing, making it more appealing to men and underrepresented groups
Low (changes in marketing materials))
Update department-level recruitment materials to reflect a more inclusive view of nursing, ensuring men are not excluded by traditional stereotypes. Include visuals and language that represent the diversity of the profession. Update the institutional websites and see if in the faculty venues there are no stereotypes enforcing images left
Faculty
Encourage male students to participate in peer mentoring programs and act as role models for others
Midterm
(1-2 years)
Reduces dropout rates, fosters a supportive community, and builds leadership among male students
Moderate (coordination and follow-up costs)
Motivate male nursing students to take an active role in peer-mentoring programs, supporting new or struggling students and acting as visible role models to increase retention
Faculty
Incorporate diversity, inclusion, and gender equality training within the nursing curriculum for all students
Long-term
(2-4 years)
Ensures all nursing students are prepared to address diversity issues in healthcare settings
Moderate (curriculum updates, responsible teaching staff working hours)
Introduce mandatory coursework that covers gender equality, inclusion, and the benefits of diversity in healthcare. This can help male students of all genders to understand their role in providing inclusive care while also reflecting on their own position in the healthcare landscape. It is important that female students undergo the same exercise, thus, strengthening the overall awareness of diversity
Faculty of Nursing
Engage the faculty of nursing in networking with other universities and countries in Nordic region to address workforce needs and gender diversity in health education
Medium-term
Strengthening faculty leadership and collaboration with external institutions will lead to better strategies for balancing gender diversity in the health workforce
Moderate (networking costs)
The nursing faculty should actively participate in national and international networks, contributing to concrete solutions that align with workforce demands in the health and care sector. Faculty leadership is key to driving these initiatives
Faculty
Create mentorship programs that link students with experienced male nurses to support career guidance and retention
Short-term
(1 year)
Provides male students with mentorship opportunities, increasing their likelihood of remaining in the program and thriving in the profession
Moderate (mentorship program costs, mentor compensation)
Establish formal mentorship programs at the faculty level, connecting male students with experienced professionals in the field for career development and support. Male mentors can help guide students through challenges and build a professional network and support platform with a long-term impact
University
Build a support system for field work placements, ensuring the work environment is welcoming for male students
Mid-term
(2 years)
Improves male student retention and enhances their learning experience during clinical practice (field work)
Low to moderate (collaboration and coordination costs with placement sites)
Work with clinical placement partners to ensure a supportive and inclusive environment for male students during their fieldwork – clinical practice, which is critical since 50% of their education occurs in real-world settings. Besides targeting male nurses as cooperation partners in this clinical practice, this might include also educating clinical staff in general on gender diversity and inclusion
University
Appoint a gender diversity officer or committee to oversee diversity initiatives targeted at diversity levels among students 
Long-term (constant)
Increases institutional accountability for gender diversity in nursing and healthcare professions
Moderate (salary or committee costs)
Establish a dedicated role or committee within the university to focus on gender diversity among students. This role would ensure sustained attention on the issue and help coordinate efforts across various departments and faculties. In addition, this could lead to better collaboration with industry partners that could be instrumental in helping to reach the diversity goals at the university
University
Organize seminars and conferences on diversity and gender balance across healthcare professions at the university level
Mid-term
(1-2 years)
Promotes dialogue and collaboration across healthcare fields, sharing best practices for gender diversity and balance
Moderate (event costs, speaker fees)
Host university-level seminars and conferences to bring together healthcare faculty, professionals, and students to discuss and strategize around improving gender diversity in nursing and related professions. Universities should become more active players that not only work on their own diversity aspects but keeps the discussion alive at broader level
University
Develop and implement a university-wide action plan on diversity and gender equality in health education and care programs
Medium to
Long-term
High impact on increasing diversity and gender balance in line with national goals
Moderate (depending on the scale)
The plan should address gender imbalance among students, referring to the existing national/official reports on men and gender equality. It should connect to national diversity and gender equality goals. Central management involvement and ownership is essential
Ministry of Education/
National Level
Push for funding in nursing education similar to STEM programs to support gender diversity initiatives
Long-term
(3+ years)
Increases funding for initiatives aimed at improving male participation in nursing, making long-term projects more viable through co-financing or support platforms with industry partners 
High (government funding allocation)
Advocate for national-level funding for gender diversity in nursing education. This would provide the financial backing for long-term initiatives and help universities and colleges develop sustainable programs, just as is seen in STEM fields
Ministry of Education/National Level
Quotas for the underrepresented genders in nursing and other unbalanced fields of studies
Long-term
(3+ years)
Provides an advantage to the underrepresented genders in admissions 
Moderate (depending on resistance)
While this measure was not implemented in this project, research shows that gender quotas of around 20% for the underrepresented genders can help improve gender balance. This approach is set to be implemented at institutions in Norway in the future. We recommend adopting the same measure across the rest of the Nordic countries
Ministry of Education/National Level
Develop outreach programmes targeting boys in schools to encourage them to explore nursing and healthcare professions
Long-term
(3-5 years)
Creates early awareness of nursing as a career option for boys, contributing to long-term cultural shifts in gender roles in the profession
High (programme development, outreach costs)
Implement outreach initiatives at a national level to encourage boys to explore nursing and caregiving professions. This could include partnerships with schools, creating opportunities for internships, workshops and job-shadowing experiences to introduce boys and young men to nursing roles
Ministry of Education/National Level
Ensure that all nursing students, regardless of gender, are educated on inclusion, equality and diversity
Long-term
(5+ years)
Strengthens the ability of the healthcare workforce to provide equitable care to diverse populations
Low (curriculum requirements set at a national level)
Mandate the inclusion of courses on diversity and equality in all nursing programmes nationwide, ensuring that nursing graduates are equipped to work in increasingly diverse healthcare settings and understand the impact of gender dynamics on patient care
International (Nordic Collaboration)
Continue international collaboration across Nordic countries to gather data, analyse trends and promote gender diversity
Long-term
(5+ years)
Provides valuable insights into how gender diversity can be improved across multiple healthcare systems, leading to more effective strategies
High (international research projects, data collection, analysis)
Build on existing Nordic collaboration projects to conduct in-depth research into gender diversity in nursing and healthcare. Pool resources and data to better understand the barriers to male participation and develop actionable insights that can inform national policies and international best practices. Collaboration projects could include joint research projects, conferences and shared funding proposals