Go to content

Insights from academic literature


Nordic research shows that both cyclists and motorists prefer a designated cycling lane. Photographed here: Two cars and a cyclist navigating a crossroads with no cycle lane in Oslo. Source: Marleen Mulder-Wieske/Unsplash.com
In the past decade, academic studies within the Nordic Region have begun to consider the congestion of bicycle and pedestrian pathways, crowded with different forms of mobility and with different motivations and pursuits. Here, the concept of a “separated bicycle lane” is complicated, as such lanes also provide space for different kinds of cyclists and other forms of micromobility. By hosting a wide range of users with unique motivations and behaviours, new conflicts may arise. As alternative forms of mobility emerge, individuals use available public space in new and sometimes unexpected ways, deviating from their initial design or intent. How residents move through the built environment does not always happen in a clear and prescribed manner, and while traffic rules and regulations enable structure and order, different transport mode users inevitably access and navigate public space to fit their needs and desires, which can impact upon other users.
Shared space may be defined as “areas shared by unprotected and protected road users and intended to facilitate a living city space for everyone” (Wallén Warner et al., 2022). Existing studies on shared spaces involving cyclists often emphasise safety concerns, while others suggest that, in some settings, mixing uses can be a strategic method for increasing safety among different forms of mobility. Highlights from a scoping literature review of Nordic-based studies are emphasized below, including research around separated cycle lane design, mixed mobility within cycling lanes, using uncertainty as a tool for improving objective safety, key sites where conflict emerges, and distinctions by factors of age and gender.

Separated cycling lanes

In many instances, the highest quality of cycling infrastructure is designated by a combination of design factors, one of which includes separated lanes. There are several ways to do this—whether by elevating the lane from the street or pedestrian path, including markings or coloured pavement, or introducing barriers like trees, bollards, or planter boxes. Nonetheless, research in the Nordics shows that cyclists and motorists alike prefer when cyclists have a designated lane (Vasilev et al., 2022-a). Moreover, they indicate a preference for bi-directional cycle lanes separated by some kind of barrier compared to unidirectional lanes, though there is some debate between the safety of bi-directional versus unidirectional models, particularly at intersections (Vasilev et al., 2022-a). In their review of Danish and Dutch cycling infrastructure since the 1970s and 1980s, van Goeverden et al. (2015) conclude that “cyclists generally prefer direct routes, dedicated infrastructure indicated through smooth and coloured pavement, and sufficiently broad paths separated from motorised traffic when possible or else exposure when traffic is calm” (p. 410).

Separate, but still mixed

Kazemzadeh (2025) adds to the nuance of the planning discourse with regards to providing separated spaces between micromobility users and motorised transport. While lanes may be separated from, for example, car traffic, they are not separated according to different cyclists and micromobility users, who often have unique behaviours and travel at varying speeds, despite sharing a common space. Through a video-based research experiment in Sweden, Kazemzadeh notes that these distinctions among shared space users can increase conflicts and safety concerns, potentially exacerbated by higher speeds and acceleration rates. By evaluating safety perceptions among e-scooter users using shared cycling infrastructure, the article proposes potential solutions like distinguishing lanes for different modes of micromobility and active mobility, enabling space for safe overtaking, and encouraging safety through various incentives.
Another study out of Lund, Sweden, noted that “e-bikes and pedestrians experience the highest speed differences in shared spaces, necessitating careful analysis of their interactions to ensure the safety and comfort of all users” (Kazemzadeh & Afghari, 2024, p. 1). Through simulations, their study analysed how e-bike users navigate interaction points with pedestrians within a shared space. They found that e-bike users are often faced with two choices: either reduce their speed or adjust their lateral distance. The study found that, when “overtaking” a pedestrian (approaching them in the same direction of travel), the cyclists preferred to maintain a greater lateral distance rather than reducing their speed, compared to when they would “meet” a pedestrian (approaching them from the opposite direction). Presumably, this is because the cyclist finds it safer to meet the pedestrian as both parties can see one another, make eye contact, and navigate the situation together.
Some cycling paths, such as cycle highways, also act as unique multi-use infrastructure. Falling somewhere between a social space and a traffic space, Liu et al. (2019) describe how the cycle highway invites a range of different users (e.g., commuting cyclists as well as recreational cyclists) to share the environment, though the users behave differently and have distinct needs. Through several interviews with cycling practitioners, the researchers report that, while cycling highways have a particular design and quality that enables cyclists to maintain a flow, they also host a range of users which can create conflict. The authors note how some cycle highways also include pedestrians or shared streets with automobiles in areas where separate lanes are not possible or deemed unnecessary. “The discussion of user experience and behaviour becomes increasingly important as we see an increasing heterogeneity of speeds and vehicle types such as e-bikes, scooters, and other personal electric vehicles sharing cycling infrastructure with human-powered transport (Liu et al., 2019, p. 7).

Uncertainty as a tool for safety

While the diversity of speeds and uses presents some conflict, several studies indicate that some degree of uncertainty in shared spaces can lead to safer travel environments (Wallén Warner et al., 2022). Depending on the circumstances, the practice behind mixing uses is about intentionally creating tensions among users which require all parties to slow down and become more alert to their surroundings, thereby improving overall safety as different modes of traffic negotiate the space (Vasilev et al., 2022-a). While some of these mixed spaces provide objectively safer traffic routes in terms of accident numbers, it is not always the case that the road users perceive these spaces as safe. For example, one study showed that when a street was opened to more social activities and outdoor seating for cafés, respondents reported that the street was less safe due to conflicts between transport modes and other street elements (van Goeverden et al., 2015). Based on their research, van Goeverden and colleagues conclude that “shared space has the potential to increase the objective safety significantly, which is presumably the result of harmonizing speeds, but sharing space by different modes seems not conducive to the perceived safety” (p. 410).
Within their Oslo-based study of speed variation among cyclists, Flügel et al. (2019) report that cycling speed is higher when cyclists are separated from pedestrians in their own lanes. And in their exploration of shared spaces in Eskilstuna, Linköping, and Stockholm, Eriksson et al. (2019) observed that the average speeds of cyclists were lower and had greater deviation at sites with more pedestrians, whereas sites with more cyclists and fewer pedestrians had higher average cycling speeds. It is worth noting that such results could also be due to other site factors (for example, uphill versus downhill terrain, type of bicycle used, etc.). But the researchers found that the site with the largest share of electric bikes also had high average speeds and low shares of standard bicycle users, which indicates, like the study from Flügel et al. (2019), that similar types of road users may encourage greater uniformity in speed. How this impacts upon behaviour and other safety concerns or accidents is not determined or discussed in the study; however, van Goeverden et al. (2015) suggest that “decreasing speed differences is the main reason for achieving a high safety” (p. 410). Therefore, as cycling infrastructure has expanded, some projects in both Denmark and the Netherlands combine motorised and non-motorised vehicles in order to contribute to the safety for all parties through specific design elements which, for example, encourage motorists to slow down and account for other road users.
Another study looked at perceptions of a Complete Streets project in Trondheim (Vasilev et al., 2022-b). The project involved the strategic removal of traffic signals and pedestrian crosswalks to develop an “informal street”—a type of shared space where use is more fluid and navigated intuitively among users. The researchers found that different street users faced conflict around the design of the intersections, where pedestrians, drivers, bus operators, and cyclists needed to negotiate the space among one another. The aim of removing traffic lights on the case study street was a way to enable informal use of the street by pedestrians. In some case, pedestrians found that the solution gave them more freedom to choose natural crossing points rather than being confined to one specific zebra-crossing for safe passage; however, other pedestrians reacted to safety concerns resulting from the traffic light removal, which led to greater confusion when discerning which users had priority. The removal of familiar mobility infrastructure also raised issues for people with disabilities and the elderly who relied on specific street crossings, timed in a way that enabled safe and clear crossing. Vasilev et al. (2022-b) also noted distinctions between different transport users’ perspectives (e.g., cyclists versus drivers who do not cycle). The latter group, for example, indicated that they preferred no bicycle infrastructure or only infrastructure on the parallel streets to the one in question.
With the aim of improving urban attractiveness of street inhabitants and promoting safety, planners sometimes develop shared spaces that use alternative design elements—such as specific materials, lighting, or barriers—to encourage natural movement and enable different road users to negotiate the space among one another. In their study in Västervik, Sweden, Wallén Warner and colleagues (2022) considered how different users visually scanned a shared space when passing through it. The researchers point out that there is a particular “script” instilled in Swedish inhabitants from childhood for how to cross non-regulated pedestrian crossings; however, in shared spaces, this script cannot be applied, which means attention to other objects (dynamic or static) and behaviour for navigating the space may vary from person to person. Both this study from pedestrian perspectives and a follow-up study from motorists’ perspectives revealed that both groups preferred some degree of traditional division of space, even if this is mimicked by non-traditional objects such as flowerpots (Wallén Warner et al., 2022; 2024).

Key sites of contention

The question of whether to separate or mix traffic, and which modes of traffic mix well, to ensure safe and comfortable travel remains somewhat unclear. But regardless of whether cyclists are separated from other users, one area that remains a concern is at various intersections, where users inevitably mix to cross or turn according to their direction of travel.

Motorised traffic intersections

Adedokun and colleagues (2019) studied the interaction between cyclists and motor vehicles in several Swedish cities. Perhaps contrary to intuition, they found that the safest intersection solution involved mixing cyclists and motorised vehicles, where the two modes shared the road, rather than having a cycle lane; however, interviews with cyclists showed that they perceived the separated cycle paths to be safer. This mismatch between perceived and actual safety remains a difficult challenge for planners working with cycling infrastructure design.
The study also suggested that, with regards to cycle lanes at intersections, one-directional lanes were safer because drivers could better anticipate the movement of cyclists. This finding is also supported in a Norwegian-based study (Vasilev et al., 2022-a).
Importantly, Adedokun et al. (2019) showed how design intent (by practitioners) of transport infrastructure does not always match its actual use. The study also emphasised the difficulties of unpredictable mobility patterns among cyclists with a wide range of confidence levels. This is especially challenging at intersections without cycling infrastructure, where there is no prescription for how cyclists should navigate the space in a way that best maintains their safety and those of others. The paper also raises concerns related to where cyclists stop at intersections in order to ensure visibility among motorists, and the complexities of visual or verbal contact between drivers and cyclists both in shared roads and when cyclists have a separate lane.

Cyclists and pedestrians around bus stops

Even when cycle lanes are separated, different modes of traffic will inevitably interact at some points of the journey. Therefore, there is a need to clarify—through design or other formal traffic structures—who has priority when different users interact. When it comes to cyclists and pedestrians, some studies have pointed out the challenging cases of bus stops and other transport hubs where conflicts may emerge, particularly when different users of the public space are in a hurry to catch a bus and must cross a bicycle path to do so (Vasilev et al., 2022-a; 2022-b). How this is achieved in practice may vary widely—from enabling informal use of the street as was tested in the Complete Steets project in Norway (Vasilev et al., 2022-a; 2022-b), or through other design principles that signal to pedestrians and cyclists the presence of one another.

Cyclists and delivery vehicles

A Trondheim-based study (Pitera et al., 2017) considers conflicts arising from the combination of cyclists and freight delivery vehicles. The researchers found that little consideration of potential conflict had been taken into account during the planning and design stages of a building site with high frequency of freight deliveries near cycling facilities. According to the researchers, the lack of a specific freight policy may be one cause of safety problems among the distinct road users. The study identified safety risks especially when trucks needed to turn around before and after their deliveries. The researchers conclude that “without any dedicated city plans for how freight delivery fits into the shared urban space, current deficiencies in the planning process will likely lead to continued problematic and potentially dangerous environments” (Pitera et al., 2017, p. 10).  Furthermore, they hypothesize that “the complex urban environment, consisting of overlapping yet often uncoordinated domains, as well as lack of a dedicated freight plan and/or planner, contributed to this situation” (p. 2).
The study is interesting because the site in question involves separated bicycle lanes as well as a loading area with an elevated hump to accommodate deliveries to the adjacent building. In one way, the research emphasizes the complex reality of spaces designated for specific modes of transport, as these spaces are contested and far more fluid than they are designed for on paper. For example, part of the cycle path doubles as passage for pedestrians moving cargo or for trucks turning around while, at the same time, part of the street and the sidewalk double as space for cyclists when they dismount, swerve, or transition from walking to cycling. The reality of space as a public container that serves multiple functions is revealed in such sites, reminding both users and practitioners of the temporality and social construction of space itself. Simultaneously, however, public space is not merely a free container but also produces normativity through its design, as those who flow beyond the paths allotted to them appear to “deviate” from the original design, creating tensions, blame, uncertainty, and potential danger.

Distinctions based on factors of age, gender, and experience

In the study focused on safety perceptions of e-scooter users within Sweden Kazemzadeh (2025) found a difference in safety perceptions based on gender. “Even within shared spaces designed for active mobility, female riders still feel less safe than their male counterparts, which could affect the inclusivity and ridership of female users in activity mobility” (2025, p. 7). Based on their results, the researcher suggests that e-scooter riders who have previously experienced an accident as a cyclist “better anticipate the behaviour of other users, improving their perception of safety” (p. 7). This is also the case with experience with an e-bike.
Kazemzadeh also found a variation between older and younger e-scooter perceptions of safety with regards to meeting a cyclist from the opposite direction compared to overtaking a cyclist from behind. In the former situation, which typically is perceived as safer by riders due to the ability to navigate the situation with the oncoming rider using visible cues, younger e-scooter users perceived this as less safe compared to overtaking a cyclist (Kazemzadeh, 2025).
Age was also noted as a factor of distinction among pedestrians in shared spaces in a Swedish-based study, where visual scanning of moving and stationery objects different by age. However, the study focused primarily on pedestrian or motorist perceptions and not from cyclists’ or other micromobility users’ viewpoint of the shared space (Wallén Warner et al., 2022).