Nordic municipalities and regions participating in the Nordic Cycle Network frequently discuss designing safe multi-use infrastructure in their cycling and mobility strategies. Key recurring topics include shared and separated cycling spaces with motorised vehicles, pedestrians, and cyclists on different kinds of bicycles. Some cycling strategies (e.g., from the City of Stockholm) explore solutions to the challenges that emerge from sharing cycling infrastructure with other types of micromobility, such as e-bikes, e-scooters, and hoverboards.
Nordic cities generally prioritize creating fully separated spaces for cyclists, cars, and pedestrians whenever possible, while also exploring solutions for existing shared sections of the cycling network. Physical separation is preferred, as lanes marked only by white lines are suitable purely for low traffic volumes. The most critical conflicts between cars and bicycles typically occur at intersections, where the paths of different vehicles intersect, demanding the most attention in the analysed cycling strategies. While accommodating emerging mobility needs, certain core principles remain unchanged, such as providing sufficient lane width to enable safe overtaking. However, other factors, including variations in speed and physical characteristics of mobility infrastructure, require more systematic integration within planning and design processes.
Shared and separated spaces with motorised vehicles
Nordic countries aim to ensure that cyclists are separated from cars and larger motorised vehicles in most stretches of the cycling network by designing physically separated cycling infrastructure. In addition, intersections are generally identified as the most critical locations for addressing potential dual-use conflicts. Finally, some Nordic cities present solutions, such as interchangeable lanes or bicycle boxes, to ensure that safe sharing of infrastructure would not undermine smooth traffic flow.
In Copenhagen, the cycling infrastructure is generally separated from cars to ensure the continual flow of both cyclists and motorists. The most common way to achieve this is by structurally separating unidirectional cycling lanes from car lanes and pedestrian sidewalks with kerbstones (City of Copenhagen, 2011). Many other Nordic cities follow the same safety principles. However, whether cycling lanes are separated from motorised vehicles usually depends on the volume of traffic. For instance, according to cycling strategies in Oslo and Bergen, the need for lane separation is determined by the speed limit for cars (Bergen kommune, 2020; Oslo kommune, 2015). Only when speeds are reduced below 30 km/h or, in individual cases, 50 km/h, can paint marks alone be used to separate the cycling lane from the road. (Such lanes in Norwegian are called sykkelfelt). But even in these lower-speed areas, such configuration is not preferable. Overall, Oslo seeks to limit car speeds to 30 km/h in areas where cyclists are more present to limit the chance for accidents and fatal collisions.
To create a more efficient share of traffic infrastructure, Roskilde proposed to apply the “2 minus 1 street” (2 minus 1 vej) concept in suburban areas, where two-way traffic is infrequent (Roskilde kommune, 2017). On such streets, motorists drive in the middle of the road and allow cyclists to ride in their own lane, indicated with a dotted line. The cars should only cross the dotted line when there is oncoming traffic, such as another car. Such sharing of the road between cyclists and motorists in low-cycling traffic areas ensures that the road is used efficiently. On the other hand, allowing cars to cross into cycling lanes may increase cyclists’ anxiety and create hazardous situations in which vehicles unexpectedly share the same space.
There are several areas in Oslo where cycling is allowed in the oncoming traffic of motorised vehicles on one-way streets. This configuration, known as contraflow, is based on good practice from several Norwegian cities as well as international practices. While in some areas around Oslo, this is not permitted, the cycling strategy indicates plans to investigate possibilities to expand such type of cycling developments (Oslo kommune, 2015). While cycling against traffic may pose safety risks if the space between vehicles and cyclists is insufficient, it can increase cyclists’ mobility in dense urban environments.
According to their existing cycling strategies, Aarhus, Roskilde, Reykjavik, Gothenburg, and other Nordic municipalities aim to provide more attention to busy intersections and roundabouts by making them feel safer for cyclists. The Aarhus cycling strategy notes that intersections and lanes through tunnels and bridges, especially in less urbanised areas where car speeds are higher, require separated crossings and, potentially, variations in pavement level. At the same time, the city aims to reduce car speeds around intersections where different modes of transport interact the most to prevent accidents (Aarhus kommune, 2017).
Part of allowing cyclists safe passage is by clarifying when and where they have priority. According to their cycling strategy, Aarhus plans to install more detection poles that would allow cyclists to proceed quickly over the crossings. In Oslo, the strategy notes that, while communicating cyclists’ right-of-way is important to remedy potential conflicts, the current situation is frequently confusing for both motorists and cyclists alike (Oslo kommune, 2015).
To avoid collisions at intersections, cycling paths in Gothenburg are oftentimes narrowed down before an intersection to indicate that cyclists should reduce their speed (Gothenburg Traffic Office, 2015). However, additional solutions are needed to more clearly indicate that cyclists have priority when crossing unregulated intersections. For intersections with traffic lights, the city uses cycling boxes that are placed in front of the waiting cars at the intersection, giving cyclists a headstart to reach travelling speeds. Similar solutions are present in other Nordic cities and named in cycling strategies, including Helsingborg (City Planning Helsingborg Committee, 2017). Cycling boxes also mitigate conflicts arising from right-turning vehicles at intersections, as leaving cyclists in their own lane often relegates them to motorists’ blind spots. However, these measures presuppose one-way cycling lanes and do not accommodate bidirectional cycling traffic on the same side of the roadway.
The City of Roskilde has several initiatives to address potential conflicts at intersections. For instance, their strategy aims to ensure that turning trucks would have a red light at an intersection when cyclists have a green traffic light to avoid accidents (Roskilde kommune, 2017). Sections where bidirectional cycle paths intersect with roads are also planned to be converted into one-way lanes to reduce the risk of collisions caused by left-turning drivers who may not expect cyclists coming from both directions. To further address safety issues with right-turning cars, Gothenburg uses an electronic sign on some streets which lights up to alert motorists that cyclists have a green light (Gothenburg Traffic Office, 2015).
Shared and separated spaces with other cyclists and pedestrians
Shared spaces with other cyclists and pedestrians are just as important to consider in cycling plans as shared infrastructure with motorised vehicles. In fact, since many Nordic cities have already implemented separated cycling lanes from roads where high volumes of cyclists pass by, more recent discussions now focus on the conflicts which arise from multi-use cycling infrastructure between other cyclists and pedestrians.
In Copenhagen, the PLUSnet system, covering key cycling corridors and nodes including the Cycle Superhighways and the most heavily trafficked routes, prioritizes spatial quality, intersection design, and maintenance standards, while ensuring that cyclists of varying speeds and skill levels can travel at their own pace safely (City of Copenhagen, 2011). The PLUSnet system seeks to allow for a calmer way of travelling called conversation cycling. In such instances, cyclists can ride side by side without impeding following traffic, particularly faster-travelling riders, due to the bidirectional tracks (providing the space of two lanes in both directions along major routes).
Although the Nordic countries feature both shared and separated paths for cyclists and pedestrians, the main goal is to prioritize the development of more segregated infrastructure to minimize potential conflicts. For instance, Helsinki has a broad network of shared cycling and pedestrian routes. However, new cycling infrastructure is planned to be physically separated from pedestrian paths. Several sections of the old infrastructure have also been separated. The City aims to continuously work with separating cyclists and pedestrians to ensure safety and efficient cycling (City of Helsinki Urban Environment, 2020).
Similarly, the cycling strategy in Gothenburg notes that cyclists and pedestrians continue to share pathways along certain sections of the network. It emphasizes the need for clearer physical separation, as shared infrastructure can generate safety risks and user conflicts. While in some contexts, particularly in suburban areas with very low pedestrian volumes, a shared pedestrian and cycling path may be sufficient, the strategy determines that separation of infrastructure could improve safety, accessibility, and mobility flow (Gothenburg Traffic Office, 2015).
Gothenburg’s strategy mentions that, in sections where the cycling lane is separated from the pedestrian path, it is often only done so with a painted line. In some cases, such division is considered insufficient, particularly when pedestrian paths are poorly maintained, have lower design standards, or contain uneven surfaces, leading pedestrians to walk along the cycling paths (Gothenburg Traffic Office, 2015). The municipality created a classification system that indicates how lane separation could be planned based on the level of street use (see Table 1). Based on this approach, clearer differentiation is warranted in locations with higher foot traffic, either through distinct surface materials for cycling lanes or through barriers or kerbs which physically separate the two user groups.