Go to content
Left: In Kärkölä, Finland, local food is produced with digital logistics
Right: Smøla is a Norwegian wind turbine island with smart-grid solutions

1. Introduction

In the highly digitalised societies of the Nordic and Baltic region, access to fast and reliable internet has become essential for fostering innovation, business growth, well-being and robust democratic engagement. However, leveraging recent technological advancements presents challenges in some parts of the Nordic and Baltic countries. In particular, rural areas with low population density have been shown to struggle with limited digital connectivity, as the incentives for infrastructure investments are lower (de Jesus & Melander, 2024).
Geographical disparities are particularly evident in the case of 5G accessibility. A recent study highlighted that the rollout of 5G has favoured the urban centres of the Nordics and Baltics (ibid). Beyond merely offering faster browsing speeds, 5G and other low latency digital connectivity solutions are essential for advancing automation in the transportation and industry sectors, supporting telemedicine, enabling sensor data collection critical for sustainability and agriculture, enhancing energy efficiency and more. A lack of modern infrastructure and associated solutions has also been linked to some of the specific challenges faced by rural areas in the Nordic and Baltic countries, such as outmigration, unemployment, decreasing competitiveness of local businesses, loneliness and lack of prospects (Adams & Komu, 2022; Slätmo et al., 2022).
Nevertheless, several “smart communities” in the more rural parts of the Nordic and Baltic countries have successfully integrated smart, often 5G-enabled solutions into everyday practices to enhance local economies and improve the quality of life. These cases provide a framework for examining how technology, particularly connectivity-driven modernisation, can bolster the competitiveness of local businesses, promote sustainable living models and elevate overall well-being in the less populated areas of the Nordic-Baltic region. However, moving beyond the cognitive trap of technological determinism, a notable lack of comprehensive data on the societal implications of new technological implementations has been identified. For better understanding of both the intended and unintended consequences of the digital transformation and to ensure that its short- and long-term effects on local populations are not treated as an after-thought, this working paper aims to bring the human experience to the forefront by exploring the following two questions:
  1. What are the key characteristics of smart communities (in a rural context)?
  2. What indicators should be considered when conducting a social impact assessment of 5G and other connectivity-enabled technological transformation in (rural) smart communities in the Nordic and Baltic countries?
The first question will provide a conceptual framework for this working paper by defining and discussing the appropriate terminology. The second question will dive deeper into the current knowledge base on the societal implications of improving connectivity in the Nordic and Baltic countries. The goal is to identify a set of indicators which can be used for both quantitative and qualitative studies of the societal implications of improved digital connectivity, such as through 5G. Such an indicator-based approach is designed to enhance understanding of the societal effects of solutions such as 5G deployment in these specific contexts and to identify best practices and areas for improvement on that basis. The aim is to provide a roadmap towards a stronger (business) case for 5G and beyond in the Nordic-Baltic countries and their rural areas in particular.
The structure of the paper is as follows: it begins with the executive summary and introduction, followed by an outline of the methodology in Chapter 2, detailing the chosen approach of a systematic literature review. Chapter 3 provides background information on terminology related to smart communities and highlights key characteristics of smart communities, linking them to the Nordic-Baltic (rural) context. Chapter 4 introduces the concept of social impact assessment and presents the findings of the systematic literature review. The following subsections provide a deeper analysis and discussion of those findings while consolidating the identified and selected indicators. Finally, Chapter 5 offers a comprehensive review of policies promoting and supporting the development of technologies aligned with societal needs and ethical standards in the Nordic and Baltic countries. This additional regulatory perspective helps to position the identified indicators within the current policy landscape, providing a better understanding of the policy incentives currently in place to drive technological development in line with societal needs and interests. Chapter 6 sets out some concluding remarks.