Go to content
Left: In Riga, Latvia, data collection is used to optimize public transportation
Right: The ferry to Hiiumaa, Estonia, where a digital strategy ensures e-services in transportation

4. Social impact assessment:
Literature review and indicator selection

As described in Chapter 2, a systematic literature review was conducted as part of this study to identify and review relevant publications that have previously explored and assessed the societal implications of improving digital connectivity. This review of the pertinent literature will help to answer the question outlined in the introduction to this working paper: “What indicators should be considered when conducting a social impact assessment of 5G and other connectivity-enabled technological transformation in (rural) smart communities in the Nordic and Baltic countries?”
This chapter provides an overview of the current state of research in this field and helps to pinpoint remaining knowledge gaps. It begins with a bibliometric analysis of the reviewed articles, followed by identification and elaboration on the main arguments presented in the given literature. These will be synthesised in a narrative manner. The chapter will further elaborate on the final selection of indicators based on the systematic literature review with the aim of further contextualising and refining them for use in the later stages of the present research project. The final selection of indicators will be used in a social impact assessment of improved digital connectivity in general and 5G in particular in smart rural communities in the Nordic and Baltic region. Social impact assessments are designed to analyse and eventually monitor the intended and unintended consequences of an intervention, in this case the integration of “smart” and digitally enabled technologies into everyday practices (Freudenburg, 1986).

4.1. Systematic literature review – bibliometric analysis

Overall, the publications identified through the systematic review represent a diverse body of research on the societal dimension of digital technology development and application. With publications spanning various disciplines, from engineering to the social sciences, it became apparent that the topic can be addressed from a variety of angles. However, during the screening process, it also became clear that while many papers refer to and highlight the importance of evaluating the societal implications of emerging technologies, only a limited number present a systematic, empirical approach along with the corresponding results. This was the primary reason for excluding papers under the relevance criterion. The following brief bibliometric analysis will provide an overview of the geographical, temporal and topical range covered by the remaining selected 25 papers.
As the decision was made to broaden the geographical frame within the search query, the final sample of publications represented a wide range of geographical frameworks. This is also reflected in the affiliation of the authors of the 25 selected papers. Most authors are affiliated with a research institution within Europe, with the USA being one notable exception (see Figure 3). This pattern reflects overall trends influenced by factors such as the global distribution of research funding, international reputation and established networks of renowned researchers (Rodríguez-Navarro, 2024). However, these findings also underline the pioneering role of Nordic countries in the field of digital transformation, with Finland being among the top eight countries of affiliation.
Figure 3: Overview of the top eight countries in terms of affiliation of the authors that contributed to the 25 papers finally selected.
The bibliometric analysis further revealed that most publications stem from the broader field of economics. This could be explained by the indicator-based and hence quantitatively dominated review of technology-induced societal implications. Altering the search query described in the methodology chapter and excluding the “indicator” dimension might therefore yield a different set of results. The publications that fall outside the wider field of economics (including management) are split almost evenly among other social sciences or computer sciences and related disciplines. This can be explained by the close interconnection between the technical and social dimension when exploring such topics (see Figure 4).
Figure 4: Research fields associated with the 25 selected publications.
While all the publications address digital transformation processes, only ten explore the topic in the context of a “smart community” and only three relate their research directly to 5G. While two Nordic/Baltic countries were among the top eight countries of affiliation, only two publications focused on a Nordic/Baltic case study, highlighting the need for more research on the societal implications of improved digital connectivity in a Nordic and Baltic context. An analysis of the years of publication reveals growing interest in the topic, with a peak in 2022 (see Figure 5).
Figure 5: Year of publication of the 25 publications included in the final review.

4.2. Systematic literature review – findings and analysis

As outlined in the methodology chapter, the selected 25 papers were thoroughly reviewed with the aim of identifying the indicators employed in the current research landscape to evaluate the wider societal impacts of digitalisation. This section aims to contextualise this evaluation by providing a narrative overview and analysis of the reviewed literature, exploring and elaborating on the most common themes. The structure of this section follows the format of the indicator mapping (see Table 3).

Economic Factors

As mentioned in the bibliometric analysis, economic aspects and methodologies dominated the framing and investigation of the topic in most of the selected papers, with employment being a key aspect of inquiry on the microeconomic level. Beyond employment, several authors also explored the effect of smart communities on the wider national economies at the macroeconomic level (see e.g. Popova & Popovs, 2022). Although the broader economic impact of smart communities on national economies is crucial for understanding the societal benefits and challenges of enhanced digital connectivity, this discussion will focus on more specific, contextualised findings and frameworks as a wider, macroeconomic analytical frame lies beyond the scope of this study.
Employment was investigated from various angles, predominantly by means of quantitative methods. A common theme that emerged across the literature in this respect was accessibility of skilled labour and the need to expand relevant training opportunities to address and pre-empt labour shortages in sectors that are increasingly reliant on digital services and technologies (Kiseľáková et al., 2024). Malkowska et al. (2021) highlighted the benefits of a stronger focus on digital skills and lifelong learning for the workforce, stressing positive impacts on employment stability, general quality of life and wage prospects for the individuals in question. These benefits, in turn, contribute to economic growth and innovation and efficiency for society as a whole when digital technologies are successfully integrated into local business models, according to the paper’s authors. The authors urge policymakers to prioritise relevant training opportunities to ensure these benefits can be realised (Malkowska et al., 2021).
In their study on the effects of digitalisation on youth employment in the EU, Başol et al. (2023) found that DESI indicators, such as connectivity, digital skills and digital technology integration, correlated with reduced youth unemployment across the Union, underscoring the importance of addressing these cornerstones of the digital transformation to ensure financial stability and professional success for younger generations (Başol et al., 2023). Kiseľáková et al. (2024) further emphasised that successful education in digital skills is among a list of factors crucial for a thriving national digital economy. This is particularly important for all working-age adults in the context of increased automation and associated employment risks (Bălțățeanu, 2020; Kiseľáková et al., 2024).
However, several publications also emphasised that a range of socioeconomic factors play a pivotal role in the acquisition of both advanced and basic digital skills (Gómez-Carmona et al., 2023; Malkowska et al., 2021).While these skills were mainly addressed more broadly as enablers of employment and economic success in the selected publications, both advanced and basic digital skills are also central elements in the digital inclusion literature. Social inequalities that lead to and result from uneven availability of digital skills training opportunities and necessary hardware and software continue to hinder the creation of equitable digitalised societies, exacerbating socioeconomic differences beyond issues of labour market access (see e.g. (Lythreatis et al., 2022)).
The study by Gómez-Carmona et al. (2023) delved into the challenges arising from a lack of relevant digital skills. The paper examined digital transformation in a rural context, where insufficient digital infrastructure and skills often hinder the integration of technologies and services into local businesses and other everyday structures – opportunities that could benefit the local population not only in terms of employment but also more broadly (Gómez-Carmona et al., 2023). In this context, the authors stressed the importance of aligning digital transformation measures with the needs and goals of rural populations, as these might differ from urban priorities and viewpoints, which may tend to dominate technology development, design and implementation processes through an urban bias.
Looking beyond skilled labour, a study by Ha (2022) used ergonometric methods to explore how the introduction of digital public services has positively impacted employment levels, exports, resource efficiency and the turnover of eco-industries. The author connects the findings to the contribution of digital public services to a more dynamic and responsive labour market, where resources are used in a more efficient and transparent manner (Ha, 2022).

Social and political factors

Several studies included in the final selection of papers focus more closely on the social and related political dimension of the digital transformation process. Panfilova and Popova (2021) found that cloud solutions have a positive impact on quality of life by increasing social and human capital in general and in particular by facilitating community engagement, providing citizens with novel pathways to make their voices and experiences heard (Panfilova & Popova, 2021). Exploring public cloud services primarily, the authors also underlined more efficient access to key public services as a factor contributing to overall improved life satisfaction. Life satisfaction was also explored by Hannola et al. (2020) in their study on the impact of the introduction of smart solutions on factory workers. Besides increased efficiency, the authors found an increase in job satisfaction due to the introduction of smart solutions alleviating the burden of monotonous tasks and encouraging more innovative thinking and approaches (Hannola et al., 2020). Studying smart transport solutions in low and middle income countries, Ashraf and Idrisi (2024) argue that smart transportation is not only more sustainable but also leads to improved quality of life by reducing travel times and facilitating social encounters (Ashraf & Idrisi, 2024).
Other authors also discussed the reinforcement of participatory practices in the wake of increased digitalisation, highlighting both their potential benefits and shortcomings. The need to strengthen the consultation and integration of local actors in the design and implementation of technology and employment processes was emphasised in several of the publications. This was deemed particularly important to ensure that local needs and objectives are taken into account and met, especially for populations that do not represent a majority group, such as rural communities (Gómez-Carmona et al., 2023; Hu et al., 2022; Ilie, Oprea, Turcea, & Parnus, 2022). Hu et al. (2022) particularly stress the significance of public trust in establishing digital services that benefit communal life. The authors correlate trust in digital public services with a higher likelihood of using these services, leading to closer and more interactive ties between the government and the public and reinforcing social cohesion based on equal access to information and services. In their case study on social cash transfers, Kemal and Shah (2024) explored the mechanisms that drive digital transformation and innovation processes within a society, examining the dimensions of coercive (techno-economic, regulatory), normative (socio-organisational), mimetic (international) and covert power (political) (Kemal & Shah, 2024). While international learnings, economic competitiveness and regulatory pressures can drive the adoption of new technological solutions, such as the social cash transfer systems discussed in the study by Kemal and Shah, the authors stress the critical role of social and organisational norms in shaping how digital innovation is perceived, implemented and accepted.
Closely related to the dimension of community well-being and quality of life in terms of improved access to digital public services and information is the study of potential impacts in the health and care sectors. Two of the selected articles addressed these questions in more detail. While focusing on two different sub-topics, both publications highlight the role of data privacy and security. As increasingly sensitive data migrates to the digital sphere, including medical records, Benevento et al. (2023) debate the need for fostering willingness among the population to share their data. Related to the exploration of public trust by Hu et al. (2022), the authors of this paper stress the role of an individual’s awareness of the risks associated with identity theft and other data breaches (Benevento et al., 2023). The researchers found that comprehensive anonymisation methods and the perceived benefit of the digital services in question had the greatest effect on people’s willingness to share personal data for health and care purposes. This not only informs possible privacy loss mitigation methods but also draws attention to the risks of misuse. The second study in the selected corpus of literature focusing on the effects of improving digital connectivity in health and care, by Rantanen et al. (2021), further stressed that online solutions do not replace in-person efforts, particularly in a mental health context (Rantanen et al., 2021). Similar to the arguments on employment and digital skills presented above, the authors underline the role of the inclusion gap and socio-economic factors in this context. Lower levels of digital literacy, access issues, weaker social support systems and limited trust in digital services due to past experiences or lack of familiarity can lead to the exclusion of certain population groups considered to be at risk of digital exclusion more generally due to their socioeconomic status and other factors including physical and mental health. This is particularly significant in the context of the study by Rantanen et al., which investigates access to and use of digital mental health services.

Sustainability

Another aspect that became evident from the collected data was a reoccurring focus on sustainability, which reflects its crucial role within the smart community concept. Several studies investigated ways to identify the sustainability efforts that make a “smart city” smart (e.g. Gorantla & Bansal, 2023). Santa (2022) addressed the role of the citizen in this context, examining the use and promotion of sustainable energy in smart communities and the need for policies to support such proactive behaviour among consumers (Santa, 2022). Regarding the previously discussed dimensions of social and economic factors, improved resource efficiency played a central role in the publications, with a stronger focus on environmental sustainability factors, particularly in terms of natural rather than human resources. Several of the selected publications noted an overall improvement in use of resources resulting from better digital connectivity (e.g. Berman et al., 2022; Ha, 2022; Santa, 2022) with Mahmoudi et al. (2024) applying this indicator in a more specific agricultural context. In their study on agriculture robots, the authors of this study found that the use of IoT and other digital technologies in the agricultural sector can lead not only to improved use of resources, such as water, nutrients, energy and labour, but also to overall better efficiency and crop yield (Mahmoudi et al., 2024). However, the authors also discussed the potential challenges that result from automation and digitalisation in the agricultural sector. As in other sectors, these may include labour displacement and unemployment, compromised data privacy and discrimination due to algorithmic biases (ibid). The authors further explored the overall challenges faced by the relevant governance frameworks, which need to adapt, follow and anticipate technological progress and the described risks to help integrate novel digitally enabled solutions into the societal fabric in a “safe and equitable” way (ibid, p.17).

Legal factors

Overall, relatively little attention was given to the legal and regulatory dimension of improved digital connectivity and the digital transformation more generally. A study by Edelmann et al. (2023) focused on the digital transformation in the Austrian public sector. In this context, the authors underlined the necessity of adapting governance and regulatory frameworks to accommodate and guide the new digital operational processes (Edelmann et al., 2023). The limited engagement with the topic in the selected set of articles can be attributed to the predominantly empirical and quantitative focus on the implications of digitalisation, where legal aspects are often marginalised. However, legal considerations are crucial in shaping the digital transformation to align with societal needs and prevent the misuse of power in the complex landscape of emerging digital technologies given that these technologies are particularly vulnerable to surveillance overreach and data exploitation by tech companies and other actors (see e.g. Wylde et al., 2023). The balance between innovation and regulation is a widely discussed issue that has garnered further attention in recent public debates. Such discussions often revolve around the balance between accelerated innovation and associated economic and political advantages and the safe and sustainable development and usage of technology. The risks associated with limited policymaker involvement have been repeatedly highlighted in this context, with ethical considerations, particularly regarding privacy infringements, at the forefront of these discussions (see e.g. (Dhirani et al., 2023; Nasim et al., 2022)).
Despite the significance of this ethical debate, it was only marginally reflected in the selected publications reviewed in this systematic literature review. Given the importance of understanding the policy landscape that shapes the legal framework for technology development and use, the policy review chapter (Chapter 6) has been included in this working paper to provide further context in this regard.

Safety and security

Safety and security aspects linked to the introduction of digital technologies were discussed in several of the publications. Data privacy, one aspect already explored in a previous section in the context of personal medical data and digital health care services, was addressed by several papers. Those studies integrate the data protection dimension into the analysis of potential risks of new digital technologies (Szalkowski & Johansen, 2024). Beyond the purely digital sphere, two of the reviewed articles explore the intersection between digital technology and physical safety.
Hu et al. discuss how improved digital communication between citizens and public authorities through novel digital services helps to protect livelihoods in times of emergencies and crises, including natural hazards (Hu et al., 2022). Two further studies (Lin et al., 2022; Samarakkody et al., 2023) explored the link between digitally enabled public communication and awareness services, employing the example of disaster and emergency communication and relief.
The study by Makhalany et al. (2024) investigated the use of drones to improve public safety in South Africa, finding that the use of this technology can support law enforcement, including through the identification of hidden weapons, tracking of suspects by night and other otherwise challenging tasks. However, the authors also touch upon ethical challenges in this context, including privacy issues and the balance between individual rights and enhanced public safety (Makhalany et al., 2024).

Technical factors

As most publications captured by the systematic literature review focus on a case study regarding the use of a specific (type of) digital or digitally enabled technology, technical factors are central to all the publications. In line with the literature on smart cities (and other smart community formats), transport, energy, public engagement and digital connectivity more generally are the most recurring themes, exploring how automation and sensor data can make these more sustainable, democratic and safe (see e.g. (Ortega-Fernández et al., 2020)).
Where connectivity itself is mentioned, it is often linked to questions of digital inclusion and the accessibility of stable and affordable internet (see e.g. Gómez-Carmona et al., 2023; Ilie, Oprea, Turcea, & Părnuș, 2022). Particularly in the context of the rural-urban divide, access to reliable digital connectivity might seem like a given, yet it continues to pose a significant challenge for individuals living in more remote areas. As certain services are designed to require increasingly lower latency, these disparities can further marginalise rural communities.

Key insights

It has become apparent that the social impact of digital transformation can be assessed from various perspectives. Employment, overall improvement in the quality of life, and the development of digital skills, along with heir implications, are mong the most studied factors in the current literature. While there is growing interest in the sustainability dimension, other aspects such as digital inclusion and trust remain relatively understudied.
Systems like Cohen’s wheel for smart cities (Cohen, 2014), as well as the various adaptations built on that model or the impact universe framework of Berman et al. (Berman et al., 2022) are some attempts at providing a structural framework to assess the strengths and weaknesses of smart cities and associated socio-technical systems and to advocate for greater social responsibility in an increasingly techno-centric society. Yet, these frameworks generally offer a very comprehensive outlook, which can be beneficial to provide a holistic picture of the societal dimension of the digital transformation.
However, a significant risk, as highlighted in several of the reviewed publications, is the omission of key indicators and the empirical exploration of specific bottom-up experiences of individuals using these technologies in their everyday lives. This omission can lead to a limited understanding of the unintended consequences of digitalisation, particularly for communities that are not at the centre of innovation and technology design, such as rural areas.
The absence of these more in-depth and contextualised perspectives can result in frameworks that do not fully capture the unique challenges and needs of these communities. For instance, rural areas might face specific issues related to limited digital accessibility and poor infrastructure due to the specific natural topography of their location. The adoption of digital solutions might further affect and be affected by historically established local cultures and practices. Without incorporating lived experiences and feedback from these communities, frameworks may fail to capture and address critical aspects of digital inclusion and equity.
The next section aims to address this identified gap in the literature by proposing a set of indicators for a mixed-methods study. This study design aims to better capture the individual citizen perspective on the societal implications of improving digital accessibility in a rural context, while also considering the broader economic implications. By integrating qualitative and quantitative data, the study seeks to provide a more detailed understanding of how digital technologies impact rural communities and to develop strategies that ensure these technologies benefit all members of society.

4.3. Final selection of indicators

The review of the selected publications revealed a set of categories which have been previously explored in the context of studying the societal implications of improved digital connectivity. To better adapt the identified indicators to the specific context of rural smart communities in the Nordic-Baltic region and to keep the selection within the scope of the current study, the following section will outline the selected elements that will be explored in more detail in the next stage of the project.
Based on the previously described scoring of the identified indicators (in the table and hereafter named subcategories), the following six indicators received the highest scores, i.e. scored at least seven out of ten points: 1) employment, 2) digital inclusion, 3) local economic impact, 4) quality of life, 5) human capital and 6) connectivity. To associate more detailed and precise indicators with the selected subcategories, the findings from the systematic literature review were consulted alongside key publications such as Cohen’s wheel and adaptations of this concept (including Sharifi, 2019) as well as the work by Alamoudi et al., 2023 (see Table 4).
No
Category
Subcategory
Indicators
Research questions
Data type
1
Economic factors
Employment
9.00
Employment rates
How have employment rates evolved over the past 10 years?
Quantitative
2
Social factors
Digital inclusion
8.35
Digital literacy/skills
 
Digital public services and e-governance
 
Digital divide among groups
 
Inclusive approaches in new smart initiatives in the community
Do the inhabitants feel that they have the skills to participate in and benefit from the new opportunities brought about by improved digital connectivity (IDC)?
 
Is there any support offered in terms of digital skills training?
 
What measures are being taken to make the digital transformation as inclusive as possible?
Qualitative
3
Economic factors
Local economic impact
7.70
Number and type of new and dissolved companies/startups (business demographics)
 
Income levels
How has IDC affected local businesses? (overall business demographics, ways in which they integrated 5G, identification of the key technologies, associated risks and challenges)
 
Which sectors have made the most advancements in the adoption of smart solutions?
 
How have income levels evolved over the past 10 years?
Mixed
4
Social factors
Quality of life
7.20
Improved working conditions
 
Work-related stress and monotony
 
Improved living conditions
 
Enhanced social interactions
 
Access to health and other public and social services (see above)
 
Perceived online safety
How are the changes to local businesses linked to IDC improved job satisfaction?
 
Beyond work: to what extent has IDC affected general “place attractiveness” and quality of lie based on the listed indicators?
 
Are there any concerns regarding data privacy because of these changes?
 
How widely accepted are smart digital solutions in everyday life among the general population?
Qualitative
5
Social factors
Human capital
7.10
Educational attainment
 
Digital skills
How have educational attainment levels evolved over the past 10 years?
 
Linked to digital inclusion: how is the training in digital skills being supported?
Mixed
6
Technical factors
Connectivity
7.05
Access to stable and affordable internet
Do people have access to stable and affordable internet?
Quantitative
Table 4: Overview of final selection of indicators based on the systematic literature review and additional sources. These indicators will be used to explore the societal implications of improved digital connectivity in general and 5G in particular in the next stage of the project.
The selected list of indicators facilitates a mixed methods-based approach to exploring the transformative impact of improved digital connectivity in rural or less populated areas. The overall study design derived from this set of indicators can be described as threefold, encompassing the following focal points:
  1. Business demographics: This aspect examines how the integration of new technologies has influenced the emergence of new local businesses and the development of existing local businesses. It provides insights into novel, digitally enabled business models and can help to identify key areas requiring further adaptation to allow for purposeful, socially and ethically aligned and successful integration of digital solutions.
  2. Socioeconomic and societal effects: By including indicators related to overall quality of life, this study design places economic changes within a broader societal context. It evaluates the impacts on everyday life practices, thereby highlighting the societal dimensions of digital connectivity and its economic implications as well as the effects on the inclusive rollout of smart solutions in rural societies.
  3. Broader insights on technology acceptance: This component integrates fundamental concepts into the qualitative dimension of the study design. It investigates underlying notions of technology acceptance and trust as prerequisites for the successful implementation and adaptation of new technological solutions.
By combining these three focal points based on the selected six indicators, the study offers a comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted impacts of digital connectivity, emphasising the need for a holistic yet contextualised approach to fostering sustainable smart developments in rural areas. These insights will contribute to broader scholarly and policy debates on bridging the urban-rural digital divide, providing situated perspectives that can inform inclusion, business and infrastructure policies alike. By identifying key sectors and technologies to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, the proposed model will also provide scalable insights, supporting enhanced digital connectivity and more targeted integration and inclusion strategies for rural communities.

4.4. Limitations

There are three main methodological limitations regarding the systematic literature review and the selection of indicators:
  1. Design of the systematic literature review: The integration of the “indicator” search term likely led to an overrepresentation of quantitative studies, potentially narrowing the scope of the results. Consequently, some relevant studies that approach the topic from a more qualitative methodological and empirical angle may have been omitted. However, this focus on quantitative studies provides a robust foundation for understanding key metrics.
  2. Review and manual coding of papers: The coding process included not only indicators studied in depth by the respective publications but, in some instances, also those discussed more generally. Each publication presented a unique research design, which introduced certain challenges in streamlining the process. Accordingly, the indicator table in the appendix should be viewed as a qualitative review of the selected data set rather than an exhaustive list. This approach ensures a comprehensive overview of the indicators considered.
  3. Scoring of indicators: The scoring of the final selection of indicators, conducted independently by four individuals, carries a risk of bias. Despite the same explanation of indicators and scoring categories being provided to each researcher, variations in interpretation may occur due to the broad nature of the selected indicators. This scoring exercise should be understood in the context of possible human error and varying interpretations rather than being regarded a definitive representation of reality. Nonetheless, this method offers valuable insights into the indicators’ relevance and applicability.