Emphasising the societal dimension of enhanced digital connectivity is essential when designing future socio-technical solutions that prioritise ethical considerations and align technological progress with societal needs. While building a robust, evidence-based information base is crucial for advancing the scholarly debate and policy development in the field, it is equally important to understand the factors currently driving – and regulating – socially sustainable, transparent and ethically sound technology design. Operating at the frontiers of human knowledge, often led by private companies, the challenges of monitoring, guiding and regulating the ever more complex emerging digital technologies have been a central concern for various groups including policy makers, researchers, civil rights activists over the past years (see e.g. Sharon & Gellert, 2024; Strauss et al., 2024).
In the Nordic-Baltic region, the Nordic-Baltic Cooperation Programme for Digitalisation 2025 to 2030 outlines the political goals of the Nordic Council of Ministers. These goals include subgoals such as “robust and secure digital services, safeguarding users’ privacy and ensuring that personal data are stored and processed in a secure and trustworthy way, giving everyone the ability to better control their own data” and “the goal to empower people to actively participate in a digital and democratic society and coming workforce transitions” (Nordic Council of Ministers, 2024). The policy document notes that “with a strong common set of values and highly educated, digitally skilled populations, the Nordic-Baltic region has the potential to lead by example in the use of technology” (ibid). This highlights the normative dimension – and ambitions – of technology development and the pivotal role of cross-border policies in serving as guiding beacons and watchdogs.
To understand what this looks like in practice, this chapter aims to provide an overview of the policies that, beyond the Nordic-Baltic Cooperation Programme, offer guidance to industry, research and policymakers on how the societal implications of technology development and implementation can be anticipated and better integrated into the digital transformation.
As most Nordic and Baltic countries are members of the European Union, this chapter will focus particularly on EU policies while also providing an overview of relevant Nordic and Baltic policies that currently form the regulatory framework for technology development. Five key EU policies and their transposition to the national level have been explored in more detail: (1) the Digital Services Act, (2) the Digital Markets Act, (3) the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), (4) the Artificial Intelligence Act (5) and the Web Accessibility Directive. This overview is followed by a review of Nordic and Baltic national policies relevant to this area.
The central question in this policy review is: to what extent does the current policy landscape encourage consideration of the societal impact of digitally enabled technologies? The methodology for this review is based on a narrative literature review approach as described by Baumeister and Leary (1997).
5.1. The origins of responsible innovation
Preliminary efforts to address the social, legal and ethical dimensions of emerging technologies and innovation focused primarily on the research sector and were made in the mid-1990s using the ELSA (ethical, legal, social aspects) approach of the 4th European Research Framework Programme (Ryan & Blok, 2023). The approach initially emerged in the life sciences and health-related research fields with the aim of ensuring that potential ethical and societal challenges arising from genome and related studies were addressed in an anticipatory manner by the scientific community (Zwart et al., 2014).
The main criticism of the ELSA initiative was its comparatively limited funding, leading some to view it as a smokescreen for the life sciences, serving more as a PR exercise than genuinely fostering critical engagement with the societal implications of research and development in that field (Forsberg, 2015). However, the concept evolved and reemerged under the name “Responsible Research and Innovation” (RRI), often interchangeably used with “Responsible Innovation” (RI), in 2010 as part of the European Commission’s research agenda, forming a cornerstone of the funding programme Horizon 2020 and later Horizon Europe (Ryan & Blok, 2023). Within Horizon 2020, the RRI framework focused on several dimensions: (1) public engagement, (2) gender equality, (3) science education, (4) open access, (5) ethics and (6) governance (European Commission. Directorate General for Research and Innovation., 2020). Expanding beyond the life sciences, RRI was to be employed particularly in the fields of engineering and the natural sciences more generally, aiming to strengthen researcher reflexivity while also bridging the gap between the “ivory tower” and the wider public through transparency and more direct citizen involvement (Zwart et al., 2014).
However, RRI did not fully replace the ELSA model. The continued use of both concepts beyond 2010 points towards the fine differences between them. Ryan and Blok (2023) found that one central distinction lies within the use and conceptualisation of “ethics”, describing the ethical approach within ELSA as building on a “position of moral intuitionism” stemming from “specific morally self-evident rights and wrongs in the world” and the critical application of this approach through a case-by-case basis (Ryan & Blok, 2023, p. 9). By contrast, RRI emphasises the use of “research ethics” and remains vague on other ethical questions. The authors of the 2023 paper hypothesise that this is linked to the stronger engagement of social scientists in the framing and application of RRI, who underscore the social construction of the concept (ibid). In this context, they further highlight that RRI gives greater emphasis to the term “responsibility”, shifting from the prohibitive character of ELSA ethics to a more constructive notion of designing progress responsibly for the common good (von Schomberg, 2013).
Looking beyond European funding schemes, associated discussions can be found on a “normative turn” within innovation research and technology development. Recent publications in innovation research, notably within the fields of economics and geography, have called on the research community to open up innovation research and associated discourses and policy initiatives to new, more normatively driven perspectives. This development can be traced back to what Uyarra et al. (2019) identified as the prior inability of innovation policy to consider and incorporate societal challenges, including poverty, climate change and regional economic restructuring (Uyarra et al., 2019). This argument is also reflected in the study by Castellaci (2023), who emphasised the need for a broadened research agenda when studying innovation in the context of economic outcomes and material prosperity, suggesting a shift away from prioritising efficiency over equity and material well-being over social justice (Castellacci, 2023). Building on the debate around the “normative turn” in innovation research, Binz and Castaldi (2024) suggest three pathways towards a more holistic and equitable approach. These pathways cover a broader conceptualisation of the innovation concept, a critical assessment of the institutional dynamics and a stronger focus on identifying and addressing spatial disparities in innovation and ensuring that these findings are fed into the relevant policy debates (Binz & Castaldi, 2024).
While the scholarly debate regarding the “normative turn” and the overlaps and complementary aspects of ELSA and RRI approaches persists, it continues to raise awareness within the research community of its social responsibilities and to foster a more interdisciplinary approach to technology development. Such multidisciplinarity is essential for comprehending the complexity of the societal implications that arise from disruptive innovation.
However, the debate originates and resonates primarily within scientific circles, with ELSA and RRI mainly applying to research practices within a European research context. Although these frameworks play a critical role in countering the prevalence of techno-centrism and determinism, it is worth noting that, rather than being developed as part of publicly funded research projects, many digital technologies originate from privately funded companies. These are generally not obliged to adhere to the same guidelines and regulations, nor are they necessarily attuned to the most recent scholarly debates on the topic. This is where national and international legal frameworks assume an increasingly important role. The following section will therefore explore four key European policies in this respect in more detail.
5.2. Overview of relevant EU policies
This section will focus on six initiatives and regulations that have been developed and implemented at the EU level in recent years: (1) the Web Accessibility Directive, (2) the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), (3) the Digital Markets Act, (4) the Digital Services Act, (5) the Artificial Intelligence Act and (6) the Gigabit Infrastructure Act (see Figure 6).